According to the consulting firm McKinsey & Co., only 15% of top healthcare and life sciences organizations in the U.S. have a physician in the CEO role; however, approximately 60% of physicians responding to a survey indicated an interest in the CEO role while also expressing their impression that they were being overlooked.[1] If physicians, who are considered the leader of the clinical team, are being overlooked for leadership roles, it does not bode well for other clinicians, such as Physician Assistants, Nurse Practitioners, Registered Nurses and other licensed or certified clinical professionals who may be interested in and qualified for healthcare leadership roles.
This is unfortunate because clinical experience brings an invaluable perspective to the business of healthcare. As more and more health workers experience burnout in their clinical roles as a result of administrative burdens, a shortage of clinicians resulting in too few clinicians to adequately manage patient loads, and emotional burdens, clinicians may seek out new roles in administration and management.[2] These administrative and managerial roles allow the clinician to use their clinical expertise and experience to hopefully improve the system to reduce burnout and to generally improve overall patient experience and outcomes.
Although the healthcare and medical services industry is ultimately a business, it is a special type of business subject to a unique economic model. In many cases, medical services are not optional, patients do not always have a chance to shop-around for services on the basis of cost or quality, and medical services are so specialized, patients don’t know what they need and they put trust in their provider to do what’s best for them.[3]
In the end, although the provision of medical services is a business, the customer is a patient who is an imperfect consumer; they are shopping for services from a place of uncertainty, opacity, and in many cases, fear. The person selling them services is the very same person counseling them on what they need from a position of esteem and trust, this is why the clinicians’ perspective is so important to leadership roles in the healthcare industry.
It is this clinical perspective which is important in making business decisions[4]. Clinicians, such as physicians, physician assistants, nurse practitioners, registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, certified nurse assistants and other therapists and technicians, are the ones with front-row seats to issues which impact patient experience, operational efficiencies, and employee satisfaction. Moreover, while physicians have a good perspective on these issues, clinicians who serve in other roles may have an even better perspective since they are the ones carrying out orders and working even closer with the patients.
So how can more physicians and clinicians take on more leadership and executive roles outside of just Chief Medical or Chief Nursing Officer? The obvious answer is more training and education specific to the business of healthcare such as business basics, strategic planning, and leadership (among other topics). The primary question is the timing – individuals training for clinical roles need to focus on the specifics of that role as well as passing the qualifying exam needed for licensure, so any additional education or training needs to be incidental to this training and timed to provide the maximum benefit.
Here are four ways clinicians can prepare for healthcare leadership roles:
There are many different types of programs which can provide clinicians training in business, operational, leadership and other subjects relevant to improving operational efficiencies and clinical outcomes, financial management, implementation and optimization of information technology tools, and leading complex organizations. Many national and state professional associations, such as the American Medical Association,[5] the American Nursing Association,[6] and the Michigan Health and Hospital Association[7] offer trainings and certifications in business topics, although the focus tends to be on leadership development for healthcare professionals.
Universities offer degree programs such as a Master’s degree in Healthcare Administration, Healthcare Management, Business Administration (with a specialization in Healthcare), Public Health and other specialty areas, such as Innovation and Health Informatics. These Master’s programs tend to be between 30 and 60 credits, can take two or more years to earn, and can cost anywhere between $24,000 upwards of $100,000+.
Many Universities are breaking their Master’s curriculum up into specialized areas referred to as Certificates which focus on a specific topic (like Leadership, Financial Management, Information Technology and Analytics, or Compliance and Risk Management). These Certificates can be earned by taking 3-5 courses and can take months instead of years and in most cases will apply towards a full Master’s degree (if the full degree is fulfilled within a certain amount of time, typically five years).
One of the benefits of pursuing a professional program, a Master’s program or a Certificate is the chance to interact with, and network with, other types of professionals in your field as well as other fields. Some programs maintain exclusive cohorts just for certain types of professionals (such as Physician Executive programs) while others will include all types of clinicians in a cohort (allowing physicians to interact with registered nurses in class discussions and course work). The typical program groups clinicians and administrators in the same cohort and allows them to learn from each other’s experiences and perspectives.
Given the length and structure of medical school, physicians may benefit from specialized healthcare management education at various points throughout their education and training. Given their role in the clinical hierarchy, physicians are seen as leaders the minute they don their crisp white lab coat and enter the clinical setting. As such, they may benefit from a general healthcare management course providing a general overview of the healthcare industry and additional courses with an emphasis on leadership.
Newly licensed physicians would also benefit from further healthcare management/business and leadership education and training as they are preparing to begin their residency programs and within the first few years of these programs. As a resident, the newly-minted physician is seen as (and serves as) a clinical leader in their respective healthcare facility. Residents, and particularly those aspiring to a chief resident position, would benefit from additional management, business and leadership training to thrive in this role and maximize their impact on patient experience and organizational behavior. Courses at this point would involve further training on leadership, but with more of a focus on strategic planning, team dynamics and professional development.
Physician Assistants (PAs) and Nurse Practitioners (NPs) play an important and somewhat unique role in the healthcare system and this role is growing. The Bureau of Labor Statistics projects NPs to be the fastest growing occupation in the U.S. (projected to grow by 41% between 2025 and 2035) and PAs as the eleventh-fastest growing occupation in the U.S. (projected to grow by 21% between the same time period).[8] Both NP (with a median salary of $132,300/year) and PA occupations (with a median salary of $135,880/year)[9] have strong pay and require roughly 3-6 years of post-undergrad training, which is far less than medical school. Both NPs and PAs typically work fairly independently (depending on the state they work in, with NPs having the ability to operate their own primary care clinics in certain states) and generally have good quality of life. Given their relative independence, and the ability in some cases to own and operate their own practices, it would benefit NPs and PAs to receive certain basis management, business and leadership training early in their careers.
Registered Nurses (RNs) are the backbone of the U.S. healthcare system, spending the most time with patients and playing a crucial and invaluable role on the clinical team. The road to becoming a RN is a challenging one with education beginning at the associate degree or bachelor degree level and concluding with a licensure exam, and ultimately state licensure, in the state in which they are going to practice. Consistent with the nature of the position, clinical education, training, and experience should take precedence early in a RN’s career. Additional training in the business of healthcare would accelerate a RN’s advancement to more administrative roles with a Master’s degree in Healthcare Management or Administration the most beneficial degree program; however, starting with a Certificate can assist the RN with getting back into the rigors of graduate-level courses and learning new concepts an skills from expert faculty and from other students who come from different academic and professional backgrounds.
There are many different “assistant” or ancillary-type roles that provide important clinical services in the U.S. healthcare system. This category includes certified nurse assistants, physical therapy assistants, ophthalmology assistants, dental hygienists, and other roles such as patient care technicians and phlebotomists. All of these roles interact with patients as well as the other clinical staff and play an important role in the patient’s overall experience and quality outcomes. Many of these roles, such as psychiatric technicians, ophthalmic medical technicians, occupational therapy assistants, hearing aid specialists, and home health and personal care aides are on the Bureau of Labor Statistics top twenty fastest-growing occupations list (for the period between 2025-2035).[10] These roles also bring a valuable perspective to both the clinical team as well as the administrative-team. With additional leadership and business training, ancillary providers can make a valuable contribution to healthcare management and operations roles.
In conclusion, the clinical perspective that clinicians bring to their roles is sorely needed in healthcare leadership roles. At the root of any and all healthcare organizations is the patient experience and clinicians have a unique and important role in this experience. Clinicians also see the impact of business, administrative, and organizational decisions from the inside out and can offer valuable perspective on the real-life impact of these decisions. This clinical perspective and training, coupled with additional business, healthcare administration, and leadership training, can help healthcare organizations combat clinician burnout, improve patient experience and satisfaction scores, and improve efficiencies across the healthcare organization. Regardless of the type of healthcare organization, a clinician with additional healthcare business and leadership training would make an excellent executive leader.
Whether you’re exploring leadership opportunities or considering additional education, Michigan State University’s Broad College of Business can help you better understand your options. Connect with our Assistant Director of Healthcare Management, Julie Delgado, at delgadof@msu.edu to start a conversation about your career goals and pathways forward for clinical leadership, or apply directly if you’re ready to take the next step.